Arnolfo
This is a serious red wine list, 389 bottles deep with reds making up 231 of them, built squarely around Tuscany, which accounts for 218 listings. Think Castello di Ama, Montevertine, and Ornellaia, the kind of Sangiovese and Super Tuscan depth you would expect from a two star kitchen in Colle di Val d'Elsa. Beyond the home turf it leans into Piemonte with strong showings from Gaja and Giacomo Conterno, plus pockets of Sicilia, Bourgogne, and Bordeaux, and there are 14 magnums for the big tables. Pricing sits in a premium range, with native examples running from 120 to 280 euros, so this is not a casual order. There is no wine by the glass at all, so every recommendation means committing to a bottle, which rewards guests who know what they want and trust you to point them deeper into Tuscany.