CruRank
Montauk, New York, USA · Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence

Mavericks

This is a big, red leaning list, 381 bottles with reds outnumbering whites better than two to one, and it is built around depth rather than a single signature region. The strengths are real Champagne presence through Louis Roederer, a serious run of Chateau Musar, and a rosé anchor in Domaines Ott, while the top end climbs into Domaine de la Romanee Conti and Chateau Rayas for guests who want to spend. Prices run from $16 all the way to $4,200 with a median around $221, so there is honest range, but the heart of the buying lives in the low hundreds. The 19 glass pours are modest against the size of the list, so steer most tables toward bottles. There is also a genuine skin contact and orange section, 17 wines deep, which rewards the curious drinker who wants something off the usual track.

381
Wines
293
Producers
1995 to 2022
Vintages
$16 to $4,200
By the bottle

Visit restaurant ↗

Champagne & Sparkling19

NVBig And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$351
NVWines By The Glassby the glass
$38
$18

White85

$1,200
2006White Wine
$296
2021White Wine
$268
2000White Wine
$255
2010White Wine
$247
2015White Wine
$244
2020Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$238
2021White Wine
$203
2020Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$185
2016White Wine
$175
2022White Wine
$125
$125
2021White Wine
$113
$98
$97
$95
2022White Wine
$90
$75
2021White Wine
$68
$65
$52
2021Wines By The Glassby the glass
$28
2020Wines By The Glassby the glass
$24
2020Wines By The Glassby the glass
$22
2022Wines By The Glassby the glass
$20
2022Wines By The Glassby the glass
$20

Rosé3

2021Wines By The Glassby the glass
$32
2022Wines By The Glassby the glass
$18

Orange17

2018Skin Contact
$173
$160
$155
$155
$145
2017Skin Contact
$131
2021Skin Contact
$56
$47

Red213

$2,400
2018Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$1,800
2013Big And Bigger Bottles3000ml
$1,750
$1,400
$1,250
2015Big And Bigger Bottles6000ml
$1,185
2018Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$950
2006Red Wine
$925
2008Red Wine
$875
$850
$850
2017Red Wine
$840
2009Red Wine
$825
2014Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$785
2018Red Wine
$775
2011Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$775
$757
$598
$561
$558
2009Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$550
2015Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$534
2009Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$489
2020Big And Bigger Bottles3000ml
$486
2020Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$464
2019Red Wine
$459
$390
$365
2016Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$345
2017Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$325
$325
2010Red Wine
$295
$282
2013Red Wine
$265
$257
2016Red Wine
$245
2018Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$226
2019Red Wine
$215
2019Red Wine
$195
$190
$190
$187
$175
$170
$150
$115
2019Red Wine
$98
$95
$75
2018Wines By The Glassby the glass
$38
2020Wines By The Glassby the glass
$34
NVWines By The Glassby the glass
$26
2020Wines By The Glassby the glass
$22
2020Wines By The Glassby the glass
$18

Dessert & Fortified11

2011AprèS Dinner
$375
1997AprèS Dinner
$275
2014AprèS Dinner
$225
$189
2020AprèS Dinner375ml
$75
NVWines By The Glassby the glass
$24
$22

Other33

2019Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$375
$375
2021Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$335
2022Big And Bigger Bottles3000ml
$325
2015Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$322
$315
2021Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$309
2017Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$286
NVBubbly375ml
$276
$265
2014Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$250
2016Big And Bigger Bottles1500ml
$193
$180
2019Wines By The Glassby the glass
$24
2021Wines By The Glassby the glass
$18
NVWines By The Glassby the glass
$16
Captured from the restaurant's published list · organized by type · prices as printed · Most-listed wines
The Friday recap
The week's sale prices, records and movers. One email, no noise.