CruRank
Warren, Ohio, USA · Wine Spectator Best of Award of Excellence

Gatsby’s

This is an approachable, value driven list built for a working floor, ninety wines that lean red and stay affordable, with a median bottle near $30 and plenty under that. Half of it pours by the glass, including a large on tap program of reds, whites, and rose, so you can sell good wine without opening bottles. California is the backbone, with Mc Manis appearing ten times as the workhorse and step ups like Austin Hope and Shafer giving you something to trade people up to. There is real ceiling at the top, the Shafer TD9 Cabernet at $140, Mira Cabernet and Turley Presenti Zinfandel, plus a couple of French anchors in Joseph Mellot from the Loire and Château Brown from Pessac Léognan. It rewards the guest who wants a solid pour at a fair price more than the collector, so guide most tables to the by the glass and the California reds.

90
Wines
45
Producers
2015 to 2023
Vintages
$7 to $140
By the bottle

Visit restaurant ↗

White6

2021White And Rose Wines On Tap
$80
2023White And Rose Wines On Tap
$55
2023White And Rose Wines On Tap
$48
2022White And Rose Wines On Tap
$48
2022White And Rose Wines On Tap
$48

Red14

2021Red Wines On Tap
$140
2018Red Wines On Tap
$100
2018Red Wines On Tap
$100
$85
2017Red Wines On Tap
$80
2017Red Wines On Tap
$65
NVWines By The Glass · Reds
$65
2022Red Wines On Tap
$48
2019Red Wines On Tap
$48
2019Red Wines On Tap
$48
2019Red Wines On Tap
$48
NVWines By The Glass · Reds
$48
CruRank Pro
See all 90 wines on Gatsby’s's list
You're viewing the top 20. Pro opens every bottle, vintage and price — and the same for every restaurant we read.
Unlock the full list
Captured from the restaurant's published list · organized by type · prices as printed · Most-listed wines
The Friday recap
The week's sale prices, records and movers. One email, no noise.