Nick & Toni's

With bottles dating back to 1967 and forward to 2025, this 203 bottle Hamptons list has real depth in its back vintages. Reds and whites split closely at 100 and 81 respectively, and Château Rayas's Grenache Réservé Châteauneuf du Pape appears three times, a notable inclusion for a list this size. Prices reach into five figures at the top, with the ceiling at $5,725. That vintage range and the Rayas presence earn the list a CruRank designation.