The Rams Head Inn

Every one of the 24 selections at this Shelter Island inn pours by the glass, split fairly evenly across Champagne and sparkling, white, red, and rosé. Vintages sit in a narrow 2018 to 2023 window and prices stay modest, topping out at $36. No single producer repeats enough to stand out. It reads as a compact, approachable pour list built for easy drinking rather than a collector's board.